What can an experienced British police detective tell us about spotting lies, reading behavior, and getting people to open up? I talk with Bob Pointer, founder of the Behavioural Intelligence Academy (www.bi-ac.com). Bob is a former British police detective who has worked on fraud, counter-terrorism, and police corruption investigations in London and elsewhere. Bob shares stories from his career, including how British police used to learn interrogation techniques from TV shows, and how he was fooled by a fraud suspect. We discuss how police interviewing techniques have evolved, why even experienced investigators can struggle to spot deception, and we examine popular celebrity body-language “experts” who overstate their abilities (like the Behavior Panel, Chase Hughes, and others). We also examine how police use behavioral observations to identify potential threats in public places, why personality tests can be misleading, and how investigators can build productive relationships with people they don’t necessarily like or trust. Throughout the talk, we explore the importance of context, the dangers of overconfidence, and why paying too much attention to ambiguous body-language cues can distract us from more useful information.
Episode links:
- YouTube (includes video)
- Apple Podcasts
- Spotify
Resources mentioned in or related to this talk:
- Bob Pointer’s LinkedIn
- About Project Servator
- About the Silent Talker program
- About the Birmingham Six
- About the 1984 PACE law that required audio recording of police interrogations
- Criticisms of the Behavior Panel:
- Episode with criticisms of Paul Ekman, TSA SPOT program, and “behavior experts”
- Episode featuring Tim Levine, author of “Duped”
- Research finding nuance regarding “Duchenne” smiles
TRANSCRIPT
(transcripts are partially generated automatically and will contain errors)
Bob: “On some of my posts on LinkedIn, I talk about celebrity behavior experts… it’s very easy to quantify behavior if you’ve got the luxury of pause and rewind, and you know the result… And so, so people like, I’ll, I’ll name the behavior panel, it’s very easy because, you know, you know what the outcome is already… It’s not the same as doing it real time. I’d have more, uh, respect for these people if they did an interview where they didn’t know the outcome, and they were just put into it blind, and they still could produce the results that they seem to think they produce.”
Zach: “Another thing that really shows their lack of ethics and the bullshit that they spread, I mean, they delete, the Behavior Panel deletes videos that where they were made to look like fools. Like, for example- the Gabby Petito video, they scrubbed that. I was actually going to go back to research that because they had made themselves look like fools, they lost a lot of audience because that was one of the few cases where they weighed in without knowing the results, and they looked like complete morons. They removed some Amanda Knox videos where they were criticizing her. So just to say that, that really shows the kind of work that they’re, their ethics and what they’re really about.”
That was a clip from my talk with Bob Pointer, an ex-British police detective who does private consulting under the organizational name the Behavioural Intelligence Academy. You can learn about that organization and about Bob at his site bi-ac.com. That stands for behavioural intelligence dash academy; BI-AC.com.
I’m Zach Elwood and this is the People Who Read People podcast. I first got to know Bob through my work exposing the “behavior expert” con man Chase Hughes, because Bob knew some people who had come into professional contact with Chase and who had some interesting stories to tell. Then I later talked to Bob and his podcast co-host Ben Cardall on their show The Deductionist; I thought that was a good talk, where I discussed my views on the major differences between the domain of reading tells and behavior in games like poker, versus trying to do the same in real-world settings like interrogations. I just view those domains as so entirely different. I reshared that episode of ours on my own podcast earlier this year, in a July 2026 episode.
If you want to follow Bob, he posts on linkedin quite regularly, with observations about interviewing and about so-called “body language experts” and the like.
Actually, as I write this, he and Ben just put up a podcast episode where they analyze manipulative language used by the con artist Chase Hughes to try to persuade people of his “body language expert” claims and credibility. The ironic thing about Chase Hughes and the Behavior Panel is that someone could make an actually good show built around examining the massive deception practiced by that whole crew; someone could make a very educational and interesting program doing what the Behavioral Panel does to the Behavior Panel themselves, as there is just so much vague, deceptive, contradictory, and exaggerated verbal behavior to study in that crew of charlatans. Anyone who did that would get a massive amount of views, also, by the way. But I digress.
I’ll read a little bit from Bob’s linkedin profile description:
People are not predictable. But behaviour is never random.
I help organisations understand the human behaviour behind better decisions, stronger conversations and more effective outcomes.
My work is built on three decades in policing, investigation, interviewing and security, combined with behavioural science and practical application.
I don’t teach people how to “read” others through simplistic signals or body-language myths. I help them understand behaviour in context — especially when trust, pressure, risk, influence and decision-making matter.
Because behaviour does not provide certainty.
It provides intelligence.
In this talk with Bob, we get on some interesting topics, and I’ll mention a few here:
- The differences between British and American approaches to criminal interrogations and policing, and some of the major steps in the reform and improvement of British interrogation tactics.
- How British police study the behavior of people in public places, and how that kind of behavioral analysis differs from reading body language and facial expressions.
- Why even experienced detectives can be fooled by convincing liars, including Bob’s own experience being deceived.
- How the difficulties of reading people applies to personality tests, too
- The question of whether you really need empathy with someone to gain rapport with them
Here’s some more background on Bob’s talk.
Bob Pointer is a former British police detective who spent much of his career with the City of London Police, where he specialized in serious and organized crime. His career also took him into counter-terrorism work—including being part of investigations into the IRA’s 1993 Bishopsgate bombing. He also later worked in police counter-corruption investigations. After leaving policing in 2008, Bob continued working as a specialist lecturer at City University in London, where he helped train investigators and other professionals, including people at the UK’s Serious Fraud Office. He also worked on European Union projects involving fraud investigation training in Eastern Europe. Interestingly, Bob describes much of his career as a series of fortunate accidents, having joined the police in the 1970s without any particular ambition to become an officer.
Okay here’s the talk with Bob Pointer, which I’m starting at a point a few minutes into our talk…
What do you work on these days? I know you have your, your website, your organization. Uh, can you talk a little bit about that?
Bob Pointer: Yeah, sure. I work under the auspice of the Behavioral Intelligence Academy. Over the years, I’ve built up a way of interacting with people, and, um, what dawned on me quite early on, that y- everything we do is based around human interaction, conversations or communications.
And so I’ve built a thing which I call productive communication. It is a way of which you, you know, any nation or any person can converse in, in a certain way with other people. I’ve built that up, and, um, I deliver that and bespoke it to whatever sector I’m living, because conversation remains the same, just the context of what you put it in is the things that’s the differentiator between them.
Zach Elwood: And you also have your podcast, uh, which I I was, uh, honored to be invited on. Can you talk a little bit about what kind of topics do you and Ben cover on there?
Bob Pointer: That started as us just, uh … He’s someone I met through work, and, uh, we got on quite well. We used to have conversations. We just thought one day, “Well, why don’t we do this for an audience?”
He’s got an audience because he, um, has got his own podcast, et cetera. So we started doing that. Um, it’s only half an hour a week, and we, we look at … ‘Cause I, I think especially now with online, it’s very superficial what people talk about, and so we try to get behind it. So we’ll pick a subject, and then we’ll just talk about it for half an hour.
We, we do it live, so we have an audience, and people ask questions. And we, we cover most things. We’ve had, we’ve had guests like yourself came on. Uh, this week we’ve got a lady who’s coming on to talk about, um, linguistics, which is a massively over- overlooked part of behavior. We tend to focus on the so-called sexy stuff like behavior, uh, you know, non-verbal behavior, when linguistics is much more important.
Mm-hmm. So we’ll be talking to her, talking to her about identification of people committing romance fraud, which she’s an expert in. So yeah, we cover most things. Um, and, you know, as long as it’s to do with behavior, we, we talk to most things. We talk to people from various different sectors, uh, about leadership and all sorts of things.
Zach Elwood: Yeah, I’ve, I’ve enjoyed that you’re a very, uh, down to earth person. You know, you don’t, uh… Yeah, getting back to what you said about online stuff and, and, uh, it can be superficial, it can be sensational, and there’s a lot of people that try to amplify the mystique around themselves. But I like the fact that you’re very down to earth about, you know, your, your experiences and skill sets and if anything, you know, y- maybe you denigrate them too much.
But, um, at least that’s, uh, better than the people that, uh, seek to amplify the mystique around themselves, which I think- Mm … we’re, we’re surrounded by the- these kinds of people these days. But, uh, I wanted to ask you- Yeah … um, before getting into the behavior stuff, I’m curious, uh, and do you have a sense of how policing, do you see major differences in how it happens in, like, the US versus how it happens in Britain?
Do you have any thoughts on some of the major differences maybe in, like, general interrogation interview techniques, these kinds of things? Anything stand out to you?
Bob Pointer: Yeah, I think, um, the main difference is, I, I would say if we went back to, say, the ’80s, uh, then there was massive differences, but they’re not so much now.
There’s been people coming along like Mark Fallon and these Mendez principles that he talks about that’s trying to change the way the, uh, USA looks at, um, the process. It, but it’s also fair to say that when I joined the police, which was 1978, I had no real formal interview training when I joined, and basically we took it from, it was like life imitation ar- imitating art, ’cause we took it from the TV So we had people acting like Columbo, we had s- people acting like Kojak and, and whatever.
Um, because that was the only point of reference we had. And, um, we had a quite a lot of miscarriages of justice identified in the UK. Um, the main one being the Birmingham Six who were people who were, um, it was seen later, there was a lot of bias involved in that. They were IRA and, um, they killed a lot of people in a Birmingham pub.
It seemed to be flawed, but I, I don’t think it was flawed, I just think it was an investigation of that time. Um, and we, it’s very easy, uh, to look back on things with the benefit of hindsight, but when you’re actually in that moment, in that environment, and it was a, a massive political issue as well as a criminal issue- Mm
then it’s, it’s, it’s easy to criticize. But they did do things wrong. And so as a result
Zach Elwood: of that- Was, would you say, uh, would you say that Birmingham Six is, is kind of like the British equivalent of, like, the Central Park, uh, wrongful j- the jogger case, the Central Park Five wrongful-
Bob Pointer: Yeah …
Zach Elwood: conviction? Yeah, yeah.
It’s kind of like the British- Yeah … version of that, would you say?
Bob Pointer: Yeah.
Zach Elwood: Okay.
Bob Pointer: I would say if you, if you drill down into it, then probably the, the, the, ’cause, ’cause again, we go back to the fact that it’s human mistakes and human bias and that type of thing. So yeah, I think they are very different cases.
Very
Zach Elwood: different cases.
Bob Pointer: But-
Zach Elwood: Yeah. But as far as, like-
Bob Pointer: But if you dr- … standing
Zach Elwood: out, yeah,
Bob Pointer: for-
Zach Elwood: Yeah Yeah.
Bob Pointer: Yeah, yeah. I, I think that’s, that’s a very fair comment. Um, but because of things like that, we, in 1984, we had a thing called the Police and Criminal Evidence Act passed, which, um, said that every interview had to be tape recorded.
Only audio, not visual, which caused a lot of consternation. Um, but for me, it was a relief, because up until that point, we were reduced to actually doing, uh, an interview where you would make notes. So you would write down the question you’re going to ask, ask the question, and then have to write down the answer.
And so an, an interview would take maybe four hours because of that. And, and, um, they, they were okay, but they weren’t an interview, it was more like dictation than anything. Uh, and so for me, when, when, uh, it came in, one thing it did to start with is it, um, it showed how actually bad we were at interviewing.
Um, and, uh, when you’re on tape, obviously things that you took for granted that you, you know, that you might say, you’ve got to be very careful about what you say and, and think, “Well, someone’s gonna hear this later.” So people took a long while to get used to that. Um, and I can remember one interview I did early on where I was speaking to a guy, and thankfully I photocopied the exhibit, but I showed him an exhibit and, um, then you could hear sort of muffled sounds on the tape afterwards, and that was me trying to wrestle in my mouth while he tried to eat it.
So, you know, y- you could get over those sort of things. Live
Zach Elwood: and learn.
Bob Pointer: Yeah. Um, yeah, and with time. But it was, partially for me at that time, um, lots of people resistant to it, and we got a guy in who was coming round most police forces, but he came into ours, a guy called Eric Shepherd, who was a doctor, uh, Eric Shepherd, and he’s now a professor.
And, um, he had devised a, a form of interviewing and, um, because I was probably the youngest in the office and the most stupid, they sent me on it ’cause no one else wanted to go on it. And, um, I had like a career-wise, uh, interaction with him. He finally became my professor when I was at university, and he was one of the forerunners of what was called the PEACE model in the UK, what I think now has got another name in the US, but I think they just call it ethical interviewing or something.
But they’re all based on this same model- Mm-hmm … uh, which is the PEACE model that came out. It wasn’t Eric Shepherd that did that, but his work was before that, and he did have an input into it. And so I got introduced to that, and even now with the way I look at conversations, it’s still based on that.
Zach Elwood: Mm-hmm.
Bob Pointer: And, um, when I’m doing behavior assessments, something which I learnt then, which they called the ABC, assume nothing, believe nothing blindly, and challenge any doubt you have.
Zach Elwood: Mm.
Bob Pointer: And for me, the behavior assessment that most people are used to by seeing online and that breaks all of those.
Zach Elwood: I think it’s something I think about a lot, the fact that investigators, interviewers, police interviewers have to think about being observed later, that not just, uh- Hmm
in their department, but the fact that that stuff might wind up on YouTube also. It’s something I think about- Hmm … too. It’s like per- theoretically creates a lot of performance anxiety around like, I, you know, it’s something I think about if I was an interviewer, a law enforcement person doing a interrogation, I’d be like, “Oh, what are they gonna say when this winds up on YouTube?”
You know? It’s, I imagine that can create some, uh, that, that would take some getting used to, the, the idea of you’re being observed in these things, and I mean, it would force you to be- Yeah … it would be, it, it kind of forces you to be better in your approaches, you know, the monitoring-
Bob Pointer: Yeah …
Zach Elwood: of it, you know?
But I imagine it’s also like, e- especially at the beginning, it’s something that would cause a lot of anxiety about like- Oh, yeah … am I doing, you know, a lot of second-guessing yourself and am I doing this right, and you’re in your head a lot until you get used to it.
Bob Pointer: Yeah,
Zach Elwood: yeah.
Bob Pointer: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. The, the, it’s fair to say that, um, the PEACE model, the P is for planning, and there was a, I think it’s like for the five Ps or the six Ps, preparation prevents piss-poor performance or something like that.
Zach Elwood: Hmm.
Bob Pointer: So, you know, the more you prepare- Right … um, and the, and the, the thing is, again, um, with behavioral assessment, it’s easy once you know what the outcome is going to be, but when you go into these situations live, um, and you don’t really know, well, you have no idea what’s gonna happen in that room, um, that’s where the art comes in.
So as much as preparation as you can do, uh, can be negated within the first 30 seconds because you don’t know how that guy’s gonna perform, how they’re gonna behave. You have to be careful not to look at previous behavior and bring it into the now because- Just because they performed badly last time or not, didn’t comply last time, it doesn’t mean that’s how they’re gonna behave this time.
Zach Elwood: Yeah. Uh, I wanted to talk to you about the, it’s, uh, the fact that the concept behavior, the word behavior is such a broad- Mm. It’s such a wide concept. It’s like, I think that creates some of the difficulty in talking about these things because, I mean, literally behavior means, like, literally anything we can, we can do and say pretty much, right?
Yeah. And I think it helps some, I, I think it helps explain some misunderstandings. You know, like, some people might look at your organization, which is Behavioral Intelligence Academy, and think that you’re focused on non-verbal behavior, for example, but you’re f- you’re using it in the sense that, like, studying, you know, what people are doing and saying, the patterns and, that we can find in these more meta level patterns of what people are- Mm
are doing and saying. Yeah. And I, I think it also helps explain, like, um, why there’s, like, concept creep for, like, people, you know, so-called behavior experts kind of benefit off the fact that you can group anything into that category, right? It’s like-
Bob Pointer: Mm …
Zach Elwood: uh, because some people will say, like, the thing, you know, people loitering or carrying a package is, like, tied to body language stuff, right?
But I, you know, these are completely different areas. Like, the things, the conscious things people are doing and acting and, uh- Yeah … the, the way they present even their, their, their, their traits, their physical appearance. Like, those things have nothing to do with, like, the small n- you know, thing, body language things that we, we typically think of- Yeah
as body language. But I think often these things just get grouped into a behavior bucket, which I think helps, uh, you know, so-called behavior experts because people are like, “Well, of course behavior matters, you know? Like, X, Y, Z.” And a lot of the things they will point to are not actually anything related to, like, small movements of the body or the face or whatever.
Bob Pointer: Yeah.
Zach Elwood: So I, I’m curious if, if you have any thoughts on that, if you agree with that.
Bob Pointer: Yeah, I, I do. Um, uh, it sounds like I’m advertising and I’m not, but I am sort of trying to put a book together at, at the moment, and I was thinking of a title for it and it’s gonna be Read the Moment. Years ago, I was introduced to, uh, Kurt Lewin, who is one of the sort of mainstays of, uh, psychology, et cetera, and he has a thing called the behavioral equation, which actually says that behavior equals how a person is functioning in an environment.
Context is everything. And so by reading the person, you are limiting yourself. You read the person in the environment, so it’s, you’re reading the moment and thinking, “What does this…” Not what is that behavior, that micro expression that that guy’s just shown, shown, but more what does that person’s behavior that they’ve just shown mean in the context of the situation that we’re in at the moment and what we’re talking about?
You know, behavioral assessment, the most common one or the one that’s been around for the longest is applied behavior assessment, which is usually children, and they talk about, uh, the ABC in that again. You know, what, the antecedent, what happened that led up to the behavior, what is the behavior itself, and what is the consequence, either intended or that occurred as a result of it?
And I think when you widen your vision and think more about that, um, it stops you saying, “Oh, well, he said this,” or, “He did this and so it must mean this.” It’s more of, “Well, I’ve seen that, but what does it actually mean?” In the context of what we’re looking at and in this, in light of his behavior before and the behavior at the time, what does it actually mean?
Um, because if you start to do that, then you realize that a lot of behavior is shared. So people will try to engage with us, so they’ll try to link with us by behaving like we do. And so when you’re looking at their behavior, the person you’ve got to really ask yourself is, “Well, is that me that’s making that behavior occur?”
Zach Elwood: A note here. I cut out a little bit of our talk here. I’m going to cut ahead to Bob talking about some tactics from so-called body language experts.
Bob Pointer: You know, you see these words like baseline and all these get bandied about because they’re, I suppose, sexy and they’re, and they’re just hooks, and the people who use them, I’m not certain they always understand what they’re saying.
By the way they’re being used, they dilute their meaning for people who are professional at this. You know, baseline is now something I would never use. I would find… You know, I, I call it a personal behavioral repertoire of what a person’s doing rather than a baseline, because it’s been hijacked by people who’ve diluted its meaning.
In my, in my- Yeah … this is only my own view.
Zach Elwood: And I think we talked about that on, when I appeared on your podcast, this whole baselining thing is like-
Bob Pointer: Mm.
Zach Elwood: Yeah, it, it’s like a lot of these things. Mm. It’s, there’s a lot of nuance there because yeah, of course, baselining is important. Like, you should, if you’re doing any study of anybody, any kind of behavior, any kind of thing at all, you should want to know what the baseline is, but in the context of- In interrogations, like there’s no way to…
I- i- when we’re talking about reading, interpreting non-verbal behavior, there’s no meaningful way to get a baseline for like these small actions. Like, the idea that you’re gonna get a meaningful baseline in like a f- a few minutes or even a few hours is, is ridiculous because, A, we know that these deviations don’t mean much.
There’s, there’s m- many reasons you can suddenly become anxious and have indicators of anxiety or i- irritation that ha- you know, and it might happen randomly, randomly. So the idea that you’re gonna get some meaningful, like, scientific baseline is, i- is a, is a… It’s just false, and these, these behavior experts use that to defend the idea that- Yeah
you’re gonna somehow use these things in some powerful way. It’s just a distraction, but it also helps prevent them from criticism because when people, you know, don’t find that these things aren’t actually useful or, you know, or if people criticize them, they’ll, they’ll just be like, “Oh no, well, you have to properly baseline it, you know.
You, y- y- it’ll take a while to get as, as good as we are at baselining. You know, it takes a lot of skill.” But it’s just a, it’s just a distraction. It’s a, it’s a red herring. It, it, uh, helps prevent criticism, you know, a- a- a- along with a few other things in that area. But yeah, it, but it’s a, i- it’s, there’s a lot of nuance there because obviously baselining, the concept of baselining is, is important.
As you say, it’s like you s- for your reasons, you’re using a different word maybe because you want to avoid the, uh, the associations- Yeah … that it has now, but yeah. A quick note here. When I say baselining is important, I mean here that it’s important in a general overall sense. For example, if we’re talking about someone’s daily schedule and what they usually do, that is a form of baselining.
Or if we talk about verbal patterns, someone telling a detailed story, and then they suddenly become much more vague and rushed over a specific part, that is a deviation from a baseline. So just to say, getting back to the fact that the word behavior is such a sprawling one, clearly understanding people’s usual patterns is important.
It’s just a silly idea in the context of trying to use small non-verbal deviations to determine if someone is being deceptive, for the simple fact that high-stakes adversarial situations will often produce all sorts of deviations from everyone’s baseline, whether guilty or innocent or whatever. Back to the top.
Bob Pointer: Yeah. But also the, what I, what I tend to find is, um, baselining, you’re looking for abnormalities in behavior, um, usually because, oh, we wanna see if that person’s lying or whatever. Whereas when I say personal behavior repertoire, what I’m trying to identify that for is because I wanna engage with that person.
And so I want to know what their behavior is and what I can mirror back to them or, um, you know, to get that alignment with them. And that gives you an idea, if you are looking at their behaviors, of what are meaningful to them. ‘Cause people will signpost, you know, uh, say for instance, in general terms, people will only share with you what they care about.
And if you listen, you’ll hear them signpost that to you by maybe emphasis or the, or the way they’re, they present it to you in, in the whole. And, um, if you start to look for that, then that gives you clues about how you can align with them. And then when you can align with them is then that’s when you get the chance to influence the way the conversation is going.
But you can’t get that until you align. ‘Cause the other thing that I see a lot is, oh, you’ve got to get empathy with people. I would say I would find it very hard to get empathy with some of the people I interviewed in the police How can I do that? Um, even rapport is hard, but what you can get with only one, I think, is you can get a commonality of perception.
They understand who you are and why you’re doing what you’re doing, and you give them the opportunity to be the same so that they get the same amount of, uh, leeway in how they wanna behave. So you get a commonality of perception. And I can re- I can remember it, uh, clearly. Once upon a time, I used to handle police informants and, um, the relationship was getting a bit…
It even over, I think the guy was beginning to think that I was his friend, uh, which is a dangerous position to be in. So I had that conversation and we had… And, and it was a commonality of perception conversation. I just said to him, “Look, I don’t want you to get the wrong idea here, but I’m not your friend.
This is a relationship that’s based on this, and this is that you provide me with stuff, and if you provide me with stuff that’s useful, you might get a benefit from it. But it’s nothing more than that.” And so from that point on, the relationship recalibrated to a more professional relationship for what it was.
So I think commonality of perception is what you aim for first. If that can build into rapport and into empathy, fine.
Zach Elwood: Mm-hmm.
Bob Pointer: But most times in business or, uh, investigative occasions, it won’t get to that point. But you can still operate on that commonality of perception
Zach Elwood: Yeah, I’m glad you, yeah, I’m glad you pivoted to the rapport thing and clarified that because, yeah, that, that’s another area where there can be such a wide, um, association with behavior, like, a, in a, in a lot of cases, people group in the, the adjusting one’s own behavior to reading behavior and, like, they’re completely separate areas, like, I, I, I think adjusting your own behavior- Mm
to influence and, and get, get results is, is obviously hugely valuable, but that has nothing to do with, like, reading these non-verbal tells, right? Yeah. I- if anything, the fact that we can adjust our own behavior to influence others shows the difficulty of, like, getting useful behavior out of reading these non-verbal behaviors.
Yeah. It, it doesn’t actually support it. They’re actually at odds. But, like, so-called behavior experts will kind of, like, group all this stuff in the same category. Uh- Mm-hmm … but, yeah, so a- a- and I do think, um, it’s also, yeah, you, you point out some good points too about there’s a lot of, uh, nuance in the rapport areas, in the empa- empathy areas.
It’s not like you need to like somebody to, uh, or, or have a lot of empathy- Mm … for somebody to do a good job at, like, avoiding, you know, contempt or a- avoiding expressing contempt and, and trying to get them to open up. There was even a… I saw some study recently where it was something in the interviewing community about how interviewers talking about themselves to try to induce rapport didn’t actually work, like talking about- No
their dog or something, you know? So just to say you, you can do a good job at these things and come across as somebody that people will want to open up to without needing to, like, have some deep empathy or some deep rapport. Mm. It’s about, I think, I think mainly it seems to be about avoiding judgment and, and avoiding contempt and, and seeming open to wanting to hear information and, and, uh, you know, a- a- and it’ll be different for different people too.
That’s the nuance too. It’s like what works for some people may not work for other people.
Bob Pointer: Yeah.
Zach Elwood: You know, so there, there’s a lot of nuance there. But, uh, yeah, I’m glad you talked about the, the empathy and the, the r- rapport aspect. I don’t know if you want to respond to anything I said there.
Bob Pointer: Yeah. I think something I learned early on was that, um, people know, uh, ’cause we all put on masks.
I mean, you know, we wear masks to fit in with the situations that we’re in. And, um, y- you know, you’ll talk different in an investigative interview or a sales conversation than you would with your, your friends in a bar later on. Uh, we’ve got masks that fit occasions. But all, all that I, when I work with people, what I say to them is that, you know- That’s fine, and we have to understand that, that we do that.
But all you’ve got to do is make sure that you’re wearing the right mask for the situation that you’re in. And a lot of the work that I’ve done in the past is trying to identify how we can quantify that without falling down the, the hole of trying to type people. ‘Cause, um, we don’t type people, uh, because everyone’s an individual, and their behavior is individual to them.
So any system that you are taught that says that this is a generic behavior and this is how everyone behaves, apart from a very few things like, uh, happiness or sadness, they, they are, you know, they’re, they’re hardwired into us. But anything outside of that, you… It’s just personal, you know? So just for instance, say someone can hear bad news and they laugh, but that’s a defense mechanism.
It’s not laughter meaning happiness. It is their defense mechanism. And, um, if you don’t understand that, and if you don’t get the personal, personal repertoire of how they respond to things, how can you ever read them? And then once you factor in you’ve got to know yourself and what you’re doing, uh, ’cause people I work with, some people are quite like me, quite behind the curve, and some people are in front of it.
And you’ve got to know that you, um, if you’re more outgoing in the way you present yourself Then that’s gonna affect the other person. You know, depending on that person’s perspective, they can either withdraw or if they really want to engage with you, they’ll try to be like you. And so what are you seeing?
Are you seeing them or are you seeing yourself reflected in them?
Zach Elwood: I was reading about the nuance, the complexity in the, um, what they call the Duchenne smile. You know, like what peop- Yeah … what, uh, people say the, the genuine smile that, you know, wrinkles the- Yeah … the corners of your eyes and such, and there’s studies showing how that shows up without genuine joy.
A lot of it is a social- Yeah … thing of, like, something we give to other people. It’s almost like a-
Bob Pointer: Mm …
Zach Elwood: you know, a signal that we are using, uh, in, in certain s- situations. But yeah, just to say for a lot of these things, things are so complex. Uh, I mean, I, yeah, you, what you just said reminds me of, uh, why, why I dislike personality tests so much because I find them so- Yeah
I mean, uh, many people know that they’re just so simplistic. I mean, there’s a few basic things, you know- Yeah … like ge- general, general senses of, like, extroversion. Introversion I think, you know, hold water. Some of these- Yeah … you know, what they call the big five personality traits or whatever. But, like, trying to pigeonhole people in these various minute, uh, categories is so unhelpful I think with a lot of these personality tests where I think other people can relate.
It’s like when I, I find myself acting in very different ways and I, from day to day in different situations, and I don’t fully understand all the factors. Sometimes I’m like- Yeah … more extroverted. Sometimes I’m feeling down- Yeah … and more pessimistic. Sometimes I’m more optimistic. Yeah. You know, it’s like we, we go through all these varieties depending on all these, these factors and like yeah, trying to too exactly- Pigeonhole people I think is a mistake, and you just need to observe and be curious about what they’re doing in the moment and the, the context and-
Bob Pointer: Yeah, the mask they’re wearing in that moment, um, you know, why, why they’re wearing it, and that, that’s the why.
Um, as far as personality tests go, a, a story from years ago, which if that’s okay, I’ll tell it.
Zach Elwood: Yeah.
Bob Pointer: Um, I, I saw a guy, um, senior manager whose, uh, employee had just been arrested for stealing from the company, false accounting or whatever it was, I can’t remember now. And I remember sitting with him and he was stunned, and he actually said to me, “I really can’t believe this.
This guy was number one on the personality test when we employed him.” And, um, when you drill down into it, that was their only sort of metric for employing this guy, because he scored really high and he looked like he’d fit into the team and everything. Um, and, and, and like all of these things, I’m not dissing them, I wouldn’t diss anything, but what I would say is that they’re okay if you have something after it.
Zach Elwood: Mm.
Bob Pointer: You know? That’s good for maybe grouping people, but you then want to know who the individual is behind that grouping, and that’s where I think only humans can do that in a, in a sort of behavioral sense, which is basically what I do now.
Zach Elwood: Yeah, the personality tests, there, there’s a lot of interesting things there.
I had done a previous- … episode on the Myers-Brigg, Briggs, uh- … test, and yeah, the fact that anybody would be surprised that someone doesn’t meet their expectations based on a personality test is like-
Bob Pointer: Yeah …
Zach Elwood: mind-blowing to me because they’re so, they’re, they’re just so simplistic and people will answer, often answer the questions the way they want, especially if they’re, it’s an employee thing- Yeah
they’re gonna answer the questions the way they, the way they think someone wants to perceive it and… I just took a, I took a Google hiring test recently and I, I hated it. It was like- Because the interesting thing there is the more that these organizations try to create these tests that make it not obvious what they’re trying to do, so they create these kind of vague questions because they’re not trying to make it obvious.
They’re trying to, you know, get by your radar of how to answer it. But, like, the questions- Hmm … are so vague that they could go multiple different ways, and I’m like- Yeah … I literally, like I wa- it wasn’t even about me trying to answer what they thought. I couldn’t even answer how I thought. It was like I, I, I-
I couldn’t even answer it truthfully because I, I spent, like, 20 minutes on a question being like, “I really don’t know how to answer this because…” And so it end up- ends up being like a guessing game. Like, I just pick one- Hmm … and it means, like, absolutely nothing because it could have gone multiple directions based on the vagueness of this.
And I’m like, “So how is this helpful?” But anyway, that was just my own, uh, frustrations with some of these, uh, personality tests- Hmm … especially in the, uh- Yeah … hiring realm. Um- Hmm … sorry, Google. I, I, I didn’t mention any, uh, specific questions. I don’t think I, I violated their, uh, you know, asking me to not share, uh, details about their, their hiring test.
Yeah.
Bob Pointer: Anyway,
Zach Elwood: that was my own, my own frustrations. A quick note here, I wanted to say that I did pass Google’s hiring test, and I put pass in quotes as I don’t think it means anything. I still really hate that test, and I found it insulting and just time-wasting. I’ll also mention that this was a new test that they’d created.
If you took a preliminary Google hiring test before a few months ago, you maybe haven’t taken the one I’m talking about. As I understand, the previous version was much more simple. I’ll also add that after I spent close to two hours taking their personality test, which again took so long because of the vagueness of the questions and me legitimately not knowing how to even answer them, I was told, “Congratulations, you passed,” and then Google never even contacted me about the job I applied for.
But anyway, I digress. Back to the talk. I wanted to ask you about the Project Servator thing. I think you said you had worked with that, um, or maybe you just have some observations. Care to talk about what that project was about in terms of, like, uh, analyzing or, or studying behavior, people’s behavior?
Bob Pointer: That sort of came about, uh, when I was at the university. So I was at the university between, I think, 2006 and 2012, so somewhere within that time. ‘Cause the, the two po- forces that I was working with at the, uh, university was the City of London Police and the British Transport Police. Now, the British Transport Police are the only national force in the UK, uh, because they police the railways, and so they go all across country.
At that time, there was a lot of, um, terrorist activity, et cetera, and the Olympics were coming up. And, um, they looked around for ways to sort of combat that, what they call hostile reconnaissance. Uh, ’cause it was worked out that for certainly people like the IRA or, um, other sort of mainstream terrorism, they would do a reconnaissance before they actually attacked a venue.
Um, and so they looked around and they, firstly, they looked at the Israeli, which is the BPR I think it’s called, behavior, passenger behavior recognition. Uh, and they are, I think, are the first to do that. Um, and they did it at their airport in Israel, uh, which name escapes me. And that was looked at, and that was, um, taken on by the US.
Uh, and they did this thing called SPOT, which I’ve got no idea what it stands for, but it’s called the SPOT program. And that is the famous one because they gave shed fulls of money to Paul Ekman, um, because, uh, based, I think- Based almost entirely on the fact that he had a TV program at the moment. I can’t see, I can’t see any other reason why they did that.
And they focus very- Well,
Zach Elwood: he, he was also, uh, Ekman was promoted in Malcolm Gladwell’s book, Blink, which I think- Ah … led, led to the TV program. Ah. But Gladwell was- Ah … hugely responsible for making Ekman, like- Okay … you know, kind of a- Oh, okay … household name. I want to put a note here that both Bob and I were getting our Paul Ekman timelines incorrect, and I think I actually got the timeline wrong in a recent episode that I put out where I was also talking about Ekman.
So I believe a correct timeline goes something like this: in 2000, Ekman was already a well-known researcher in the non-verbal behavior and deception detection spaces for his work over the previous few decades. After 9/11, he was contacted about involvement in the TSA SPOT program, which wanted to use his and others’ research on non-verbal behavior to help inform their behavioral analysis of people at airports.
So they started training people in that in 2006 and started using it in 2007. Ekman got a major uptick in popular mainstream awareness when Malcolm Gladwell’s bestseller, Blink, came out in 2005. Gladwell fawned over Ekman and basically treated Ekman as he wanted to be treated, as an amazing reader of people.
I think Gladwell was a massive sucker for how he covered Ekman in that book. Then in 2009, the TV show, Lie to Me, which was loosely based on Ekman’s ideas, came out. I think that show wouldn’t have happened without Ekman being promoted by Gladwell in his book and gaining wider public awareness. In 2011, congressional hearings were held on the effectiveness of the SPOT program.
Criminal investigation and interrogation researcher, Maria Hartwig, testified against Ekman and the SPOT program in that hearing. And earlier this year, I interviewed Maria about her work. We talked about the uselessness of Ekman’s concept of microexpressions, amongst other things. In 2013, a Government Accountability Office report and a DHS Office of Inspector General report raised major concerns about the TSA SPOT program, concluding that scientific evidence did not establish that behavioral indicators reliably identified security threats.
So between 2013 and 2016, the TSA changed up various aspects of the program. In 2016, the agency officially transitioned and rebranded SPOT into Behavior Detection and Analysis. It’s actually hard to get much information about this on a quick search, but it seems that while they have toned down the non-verbal behavioral analysis aspects, the Behavior Detection and Analysis program is still running.
It’s just hard to know at a quick search what exactly is going on with it now. But that would be interesting to delve into. If you’d like to hear some very strong criticisms of Paul Ekman, I’d recommend an episode I did in September of 2026, which features an interview with Kent Clisby. We talk about the bad ideas of Ekman, of Joe Navarro, and of other alleged body language experts.
Okay, back to the talk.
Bob Pointer: And, and again, um, talking about Ekman, I won’t diss Ekman. I mean, I’ve, I for a while bought into that microexpressions when it first come out, ’cause I was at the university at the time, and I think I was fa- I was ha- I was probably thankful that I was surrounded by academics who were much more informed than the stupid boy from Dagenham like myself, who was there by default rather than because I was brilliant.
Um, and they sort of pointed out the, um, the inaccuracies or the intricate parts of what he was saying. And, um, when you look at it, he’s not really adding anything apart from a serve- uh, a study to what, um, Charles Darwin was saying. So Ekman, that was Influence Clues, and they focused very heavily on that.
It was brought to the UK via people who I know. I wasn’t involved in it, but, um, obviously the British Transport Police were heavily involved in it, and they brought it to the UK, and this idea of behavior detection officers. But it’s fair to say that the UK version, even in the early days, completely ruled out the microexpressions part of it, and it was based more on behavior.
And so, um, for instance- When y- and when
Zach Elwood: you say, like, it’s the thing, you’re talking about things people actually do kind of behavior.
Bob Pointer: Yeah, yeah. Like, like I would say, it’s like, um- Let’s, let’s think about this. Say a railway station, you would have people, spotters, look in a railway station, behavior detection officers, and they’ll be watching the crowd and their behaviors.
And they would get a, we’ll use the word baseline, but they’ll get a, a baseline for how the behavior is happening. And if the trains are all running correctly, then people should behaving in a, in a certain way. They should be going there, looking at the board, waiting for the train, et cetera, et cetera, getting on the train.
Zach Elwood: Right. And that
Bob Pointer: becomes an-
Zach Elwood: There’s an average, an average group of-
Bob Pointer: Yeah,
Zach Elwood: yeah … of behaviors that are, are even if- Yeah … even if innocent people deviate, there’s an average group of behaviors,
Bob Pointer: right? Yeah. And so they would then identify people who seem to be acting differently, and some of the behavior they’d be looking for is people who are checking out where the CCTV are, where the exits and entries are, where, where there’s, um, you know, all sorts of things that they would’ve scoped already for that environment.
And then they would, uh, identify people through that. And then what they would do is if they identify someone, they would put, maybe put in a trigger, and a trigger might be a police officer walk through that area and see how the person behaves then. But that is all contextual, so the behaviors that people would be doing would be normal in that environment.
But, and so you’d be looking for people who are not just waiting for a train and getting on the train, but maybe miss a few trains and they’re just walking around. But then if the trains are all delayed, the behavior’s gonna change completely, so you’re then looking for different indicators, you know? So it, it sort of changes with the, um, environment.
That was taken on. The City of London, uh, I mentioned earlier the Bishopsgate bombing, which caused huge financial losses, and because this, it’s where at that time most of the financial companies were, they wanted to better protect it. And because the City of London is, uh, very small, it’s the original London, so it has got still got some of the walls up around it.
And so Bishopsgate was the gate to the city from the place called Bishop, et cetera, et cetera. So what they did is they set up what they called a ring of steel. So they put CCTV cameras all around the entry points, and that was when this thing called ANPR was developed, which is a number plate reader. Uh, which identifies cars, and it also, uh, in the city st- uh, ring of steel, it took photographs of the drivers.
And you had only a certain amount of en- entrances in and out the city, so they made it one way on some of them so they could manage entry and exit from the city basically without stopping people. You could just photograph them as it’s coming in- Mm-hmm … and as it’s going out. But, but as well as that, at certain times they would have police officers in boxes at these entry and exit points who would then have the ability to get the information from the cameras and then stop people if they wanted.
It wasn’t successful in identifying terrorists, but it’s fair to say that they didn’t have a terrorist incident after they were introduced.
Zach Elwood: Hmm.
Bob Pointer: So the City of London had a, a big interest, and they got involved in it. And, um, so what they did is they had like a hybrid thing, which is about the CCTV ANPR, and what they would do is they’d identify, not just for terrorism now, but for all sorts of things.
So, um, if they was having, um, they would do intelligence-led, uh, sort of research, and if they found that a certain area was having a high proportion of the crimes committed, they would target that area for a couple of weeks, and they would put these behavioral detection officers into that area, and then they would introduce these triggers and combine that with CCTV and all that and, and create like a more overarching way of dealing with things rather than just behavioral detection.
It was about checkpoints, uh, coordinating with the local community, getting them involved in it. At the time, they used to have posters all over the Underground, and, “See it, report it,” or something like that. So they managed to get the whole, uh, through, um, talking to local community, they managed to get them all involved.
And that is what Servator was. That’s what it started as. It’s now expanded. It’s a center for protection of, uh, national infrastructure, CPNI, who, uh, were behind it, and it was taken on board and, and it’s been expanded a lot. But it’s used everywhere now. At every major event in the, in the country, in the UK, it’s used, and most police forces use it as a way of targeting rather than just waiting for things to happen, trying to be a bit of ahead of the game.
So it’s not just behavioral detection now. That’s a small part of it.
Zach Elwood: Yeah. And, uh, getting back to that, the wideness of the, the behavior concept, it’s like when some people would hear that there’s behavior detection officers, they would imagine that they’re doing these like, you know- Yeah … non-verbal analysis, but they’re, but they’re not.
They’re focusing on, you know, what people are actually doing, their behavior. So I think, I think it’s, that’s important to point out because there is so much- cross, uh, talk and misunderstandings when it comes to the word behavior. I mean, that was initially what I got when I heard- was reading about these behavior detection officers, because I think that was something similar that, to what they called the people doing that, uh, American TSA SPOT program.
They had some kind of, like, behavior analysis kind of title, but they were focused on, you know, much more meaningless, you know, non- nonverbal body language stuff. So yeah, I just wanted to To emphasize that. Yeah. And I think, uh… Oh, go ahead.
Bob Pointer: No, I was just gonna say, there’s the SPOT program, they had like a, a checklist of all the things that I think Ekman, whoever, had given them, and they were totally useless really.
I don’t think they had much success with it, but then I know you’ve had other guests saying that it was a total failure and all that.
Zach Elwood: A note here, Bob is referring here to my talk with Kent Clisby, which was released in September of 2026.
Bob Pointer: But the, the problem with quantifying this is that you don’t know, that’s the thing about- There’s so few terrorists.
Zach Elwood: There’s so few terrorists- Yeah … so it’s hard to know, uh, you know, it’s-
Bob Pointer: Yeah, yeah. And a, a police officer could walk along the road. How many crimes, you know, he’s stopped just by being in that area at that time? It’s, it’s very hard to quantify.
Zach Elwood: I agree.
Bob Pointer: So it… I, I just think he didn’t catch a terrorist, but that’s all you can say.
But how many crimes do you know or how many did he dissuade? You don’t know.
Zach Elwood: Yeah, and that’s where I wanted to pivot next actually, because I think in the same way that there’s people that promote the use of, like, non-verbal body language stuff too much, especially in high stakes domains, there’s also people that-
Bob Pointer: Mm
Zach Elwood: are much too skeptical and cynical about the use of any kind of behavior. You know, like they’ll-
Bob Pointer: Yeah …
Zach Elwood: I, I, I think, and I think it, part of it is, like, kind of a polarization that’s due to people recognizing the bullshit in the, in the non-verbal behavior space and they’re like, you know. And, and that, that I think leads to some pivoting a- away too much from the idea of using any behavior.
But I do think, you know, part of it is it le- a lot of the discussion around any of these things, like from the polygraph to non-verbal behavior to the meta level behaviors of what people do, it’s like it’s really a discussion of what is the practical value of these things that we know- Yeah … are not 100%- Exactly
reliable. Like, there can be information that means, you know- Mm … gives you, like, a little bit of information. It means something i- in the aggregate, but I think people in general are really, we’re really bad about talking about probability for one. We’re, and we’re, we’re also, we can be really afraid of doing unfair things, right?
That’s another thing. But a lot of this is, boils down to, like, what is the practical value? Like theoretically, I, I would say- Mm … e- even in the, in the, in the SCAN, or no, sorry, the SPOT program for the TSA, I, I don’t think there’s anything even wrong with, like, jud- like say you had some program where pe- if you had s- noticed somebody that was sweating a lot, just looking into them a bit more.
I don’t think there’s any- anything necessarily wrong with that. Yeah. It’s all about how much harm they’re, it’s theoretically causing, and also the practical aspect of how much extra time and effort is it taking to investigate a lot of people, right? It’s like it, it boils down to the real world harm for people that you look into and what the impacts are to them.
It boils down to how much time you’re wasting and how e- efficient- Yeah … and how productive it is. So it’s like, but a lot of these things are really nuanced and hard to talk about, which I think leads to people having all these different views on all these different, you know, is this unfair to use? Is this unproductive to use?
But yeah, i- I- I think a lot of it boils down to that, that discussion of how useful imperfect infor- information is.
Bob Pointer: Yeah, this is the, the thing that, um, that I’ve come across, and it’s not bugbear, but it is a thing that when I go to see people and say what I do, the hard thing to sell to them is the uncertainty.
When I say to them, “I’m not, can’t guarantee that this will work, and I can’t guarantee that everyone you send on this program will come out of it being a, an expert in reading behavior,” ’cause it doesn’t work like that. That’s the differentiator between what I do and what some people do, is because people like certainty.
Zach Elwood: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Bob Pointer: Um, we- we’re, we are very frightened of being in the dark about anything, of not knowing. And if you can say to someone, “I can sell you a course and 100% when they come out of this, they will know this,” then you’re gonna sell it.
Zach Elwood: Mm-hmm.
Bob Pointer: So it’s a harder sell to sell uncertainty.
Zach Elwood: Right. Yeah, and, uh, you know, a- but people, people should recognize, i- I mean, I, I had similar thoughts in the poker space because there are some people that are really afraid of using poker tells.
They, they downplay it, which, a- a- and I’m, I completely emphasize it’s a very small part of playing strong poker. But it’s, it’s a skill set that can add to your, you know, your much more important foundational strategy knowledge. But some people- Yeah … have this fear or, uh, concern about using this very imperfect information, which it is, you know.
A- and, but it’s also similar to, there’s all sorts of fundamental things that we use that are imperfect, too, right? Like, it’s like, you know, say you, uh, uh, a dog, uh, i- in the airport gets a sniff of drugs or, or explosive or whatever. That, that can be imperfect information, too, right? It’s not 100%- Yeah
reliable, but you- No … still can… And, and the same way in poker, we, people, uh, it’s a fundamental aspect to alter your strategic play based on, say, somebody raising a lot, somebody betting a lot. Mm-hmm. You adjust to that. But that’s much more easy- It’s less scary to use that information because it’s more, like, quantifiable than the, than the non-verbal- Mm
you know, behavior stuff. So I th- I think that’s why people can… are more comfortable using the more quantifiable things than they are using the, the harder to quantify things. But, you know, you can also… But it’s also true, you can quantify behavior, like you were saying, like videotaping the, the things people are doing at the train station and such.
You, you can turn that into data. You know, you can imagine an algorithm that says like, “Oh, this person was looking in these directions and loitering in these areas,” and that’s, that’s data. Mm. It’s still imperfect data, but it’s, you know, it’s something to go on. But, uh, yeah, I think a lot of these things, it’s really hard to talk about because like you said, people r- are really scared of using imperfect information.
They’re afraid of, uh- Mm … even when it’s information that’s valuable, it’s, it’s imperfect, it’s probabilistic, and people can be really afraid of relying on that. They don’t wanna look stupid. They don’t wanna make mistakes. They don’t wanna be held liable for, uh, for something or other. But I think, uh, you know, a- as long as we’re using the, the information intelligently and not, like, harming people- Yeah
in the use of it, that those are the important things, yeah.
Bob Pointer: Yeah, I think it comes down to checks and balances. Project Servator, they have like an escalation cycle, so it would be stop the person, have a brief chat with them. They’re taught to ask the right questions and, and judge the replies to those questions.
Zach Elwood: Right.
Bob Pointer: And then that would be it. That would be it. If there’s any more suspicion, there may be a search. If there’s any more suspicion, they take them somewhere to ask them questions, so it’s like an escalation path.
Zach Elwood: Yeah. The important thing there is, you know, getting back to the, the importance of what people say is, like, the, the most important thing, right?
Like, um, all the other, the, the, the non-verbal or the loitering or whatever it is, it’s like- Mm … you really, it’s good to hear what people say because that becomes some actual information you can, you can use. Yeah.
Bob Pointer: Yeah. One of the things, I don’t know if you’ve heard of, um, Silent Talker. Uh, Silent Talker was a system developed by Manchester Metropolitan University, and I don’t know, I, I, I get a suspicion that it may be something to do with Ekman because at the same university is the Emotional Intelligence Academy, which is Ekman’s arm in the UK.
Zach Elwood: Hmm.
Bob Pointer: And they run courses in sort of behavior detection, et cetera. But Silent Talker was a system that was developed for use at airports where it basically scans you when you’re being talked to by the, uh, official, and makes a conclusion about whether you’re being open and honest or, um, whether you’re a threat or however it would, uh, uh, sort of look at it.
And, um, it failed miserably. They put it in at one of the EU borders and they withdrew it because it was just, um, I think they were challenged about it maybe. I don’t know that for a fact, I’m just, uh, that’s the impression I got is that they were challenged about its validity and they couldn’t prove its validity and-
Zach Elwood: Hmm
Bob Pointer: that it was the, of its use, and so it was withdrawn. But the EU spent a lot, a lot of money on it.
Zach Elwood: So it’s like their Spot, yeah. It was their version of, of Spot, basically.
Bob Pointer: Yeah. But, but it was a, but it was a, it was a computer doing it. It wasn’t humans.
Zach Elwood: Oh, yeah. Gotcha. Right. Yeah. Interesting.
Bob Pointer: So it was a, it was a program, yeah.
Zach Elwood: Oh, I’ll have to look into that. That’s, that’s an interesting one. Yeah, I actually wanna go, I wanna make an episode about Ekman’s congressional testimony- Mm … about the SPOT program- Mm … ’cause I think that’s a under… That’s a pretty interesting story in itself about… And Maria Hartwig was testifying against, you know, the, the, the SPOT program basically and criticizing that work, and so it was a really interesting, uh, dynamic at that congressional testimony, which I think was, like, 2012, somewhere around there.
But anyway,
Bob Pointer: yeah. Yeah.
Zach Elwood: I wanna, wanna… That, that, uh, Silent Talker thing sounds interesting, too. Maybe I’ll delve into that later.
Bob Pointer: Mm.
Zach Elwood: A quick note here. Bob is right that that Silent Talker program was influenced by Ekman’s ideas. It relied heavily on microexpressions, for example, and the idea that you can use microexpressions to detect deception is bullshit.
Read Maria Hartwig’s analysis of this area or listen to my interview with her from earlier this year. But that doesn’t stop some people who I view as unethical who still promote that kind of stuff and profit off of it. That includes academic researchers like David Matsumoto, who owns the company Humantell.
Matsumoto was a protege and colleague of Paul Ekman, and his company charges people hundreds of dollars for what I think is very bad and misleading microexpression-based deception detection training. Okay, back to the talk. Anything you want to… I, I think we’ve covered a good amount of stuff here.
Anything you want to mention at the end that y- that is important to you that we didn’t touch on?
Bob Pointer: I think what’s important to me is, and something that you mentioned to me, is that, um, on some of my posts on LinkedIn I mention about celebrity behavior experts. I, I… In, in my view, there is, um, two people who do my sort of work.
There are ones who are in it, um, and decide to go along the entertainment route. That’s what I like to call it. And there’s ones like myself. Now, the ones that are going on the entertainment route are going to make a entire lot mo- more money than me. Maybe have to lay out because they have to advertise themselves all the time.
But I, I am not one of those people who will diss them. I don’t agree with some of the conclusions they come to, and for me, it’s very easy to quantify behavior if you’ve got the luxury of pause and rewind, and you know the result. And so, so people like, I’ll, I’ll name the behavior panel, it’s very easy because, you know, you know what the outcome is already.
And so they’re only human. That is gonna bias them. It’s not the same as doing it real time. I’d have more, uh, respect for these people if they did an interview where they didn’t know the outcome, and they were just put into it blind, and they still could produce the results that they seem to think they produce.
I’ve got no problem with that. It’s a, it’s a decision. You can tell them, but there’s seems to be a template for it. You, you big up your background. You publish a book. You do this, you do that. And then that makes
Zach Elwood: you an expert. You call yourself, you call yourself the world’s best behavior expert. You know, that helps too.
Bob Pointer: Yeah. I alway- I, I always wondered, uh, with the behavior panel, there’s, uh, four people there who claim to be the world’s number one behavior expert. Which seems a bit odd to me, but, um,
Zach Elwood: but- They need to fight that out among… They need to have a little battle amongst themselves, like a battle to the death to…
There can only be number- The- … one number one behavior expert.
Bob Pointer: Yeah. Uh, that, that would be good to see. But I think the, the, the point I’m trying to make is, is that I’ve got no problem with them. Let them do their own thing. It only concerns me when it impacts on real life, when people think these things can work, that they can actually watch a two-hour video of them doing one of these, uh, presentations that they do, uh, looking at, I don’t know, Tom Cruise or whatever.
And they think that that’s gonna work in real life. And there are some, and the one that you are particularly interested in, who have just taken it to the nth degree. Uh, Chase Hughes, um, someone that I know of, I don’t know him personally, but I’ve worked with people who have worked with Chase Hughes. And, um, he’s just right out there, and I think he’s, he’s a bit of an anomaly even in that space- Yeah
to be fair. I, I would, I would like to say that I’ve got nothing… I’ve mentioned them, um, and I mentioned what I think there’s, their pre- their- propagating that isn’t true, but I’ve got no real sort of animosity towards them. I just see them. Maybe 20 years ago if I had to do this for a living, who knows where I’d be.
Um- Well, so- … I’m just in a fortunate position
Zach Elwood: I think it’d be nice if the… You know, I, I think also maybe what you’re saying is it’d be nice if people saw them as entertainment, uh- Yeah … which is what, what they are. You know, it’s… Should be treated as entertainment. Um, oh, and a- another thing that really shows their lack of ethics and the bullshit that they spread, I mean, they delete, the Behavior Panel deletes videos that, where they were made to look like fools.
Like, for example-
Bob Pointer: Yeah …
Zach Elwood: the Gabby Petito video, they scrubbed that. Uh, I could… I, I was- Yeah … actually going back to research that because they had made themselves look like fools. Their own… They lost a lot of audience because that was one of the few cases where they weighed in without knowing the results, and they look like complete morons.
And, uh, they scrubbed that from the internet. I was act- I wish I had saved it at the time, but, uh, they removed that. They removed some Amanda Knox videos where they were criticizing her. So just to say, that, that really shows the kind of-
Bob Pointer: Yeah …
Zach Elwood: work that they’re, their ethics and what they’re really about because, you know, a, a…
If you’re really a public, a, a serious thinker, a serious public thinker, you don’t go back and delete the times you were wrong. If anything, you talk about that and what you learned from it, right? But they’re, they also delete critical and skeptical comments from all their social media to make themselves look more intelligent.
They have a small army of people- Mm … I’m told by people who used to do that. They, they delete- Mm … all the comments to make themselves look smarter. Anyway, um, think we’re on the same page there.
Bob Pointer: A quick note here.
Zach Elwood: Another thing I noticed recently was that the Behavior Panel had stopped allowing public comments on YouTube, and now they only allow subscribers to leave comments.
I’m sure my exposure of Chase Hughes as a pathological liar and con artist was a factor in them making their comments only available to subscribers. Mark Bowden, Greg Hartley, and Scott Rouse, these people who exaggerate their abilities and help promote someone as clearly unethical and frankly dangerous as Chase Hughes, they should all be ashamed of themselves.
But they are bullshitters and con artists themselves, and seem to be incapable of shame and responsibility.
Bob Pointer: Back to the talk.
Zach Elwood: I wanted to get your take as somebody… You know, you’re somebody who has done policing and interviewing and interrogation. I mean, one thing I started thinking about recently as I was, I was working on my book too, I’m working on a, a book.
I started thinking about, you know, why is it that practitioners like police officers can really believe there is something in this non-verbal stuff when it comes to deception detection, guilt detection? I, uh, and I do think, you know, I think that’s worth dwelling on because I think, you know, police officers- Mm
investigators, they’re not stupid. They’re, they’re noticing something there, I think. And, and I think the thing that stands out to me is when I was thinking about Tim Le- Levine’s, Tim Levine’s work on- Mm … um, you know, deception detection, his great book, Duped.
Bob Pointer: Mm-hmm.
Zach Elwood: I think he has a- Yeah … very val- valid point that the reason for the above average, uh- Rating like the 55 to 60%, uh, accuracy you see in a lot of the non-verbal dece- deception detection studies is due to the fact that there are a small number of people who could be t- termed bad liars.
Like they have a lot of, uh, behaviors when lying that we associate as indicators of anxiety and indicators of lying- Yeah … you know, these kind of stereotypical like self-soothing- Yes … or, you know, maybe blushing- Mm … or touching their face when… You know, so those things show up from innocent people too, which is why they’re bad indicators of lying.
But for a small percentage of people, they consistently display those things- Mm … and people are consistently noticing them when they do these studies and such, right? So that helps explain why there’s an above average rating there. But I- it got me thinking of like for practitioners, and I- I’ve watched a lot of interrogation footage myself, and I do think there’s these small number of people that off the bat in these interrogation settings, they’re like doing a lot of these stereotypical like self-soothing, they’re touching themselves.
Bob Pointer: Mm.
Zach Elwood: It got me thinking about when I was reading this book by Stan Walters, he had this book, I was reading this from 2000, uh, an old book, uh, about it was called like Kinesic Interviewing, but it had all these screensho- uh, these, these images of people, you know, uh, suspects like self-soothing, touching their body, touching their face.
By the way, I recently interviewed Stan Walters, the author of that book, for the podcast, and he describes his journey of moving away from thinking that non-verbal behavior was a
Bob Pointer: useful thing to pay attention to in criminal interrogation domains. So that was a talk from October of 2026. Back to the talk.
Zach Elwood: And, and having watched a good amount of interrogations itself, I do think there’s, especially when you’re taking into context that practitioners have a lot of experience in these, these settings, there are some people that probably very immediately come across as, uh, highly nervous in a non-verbal way, highly anxious in unusual ways- Mm
that from context a lot of practitioners would be like, “We know it would be very unusual for an innocent person to, off the bat, act this way,” right? So it got me thinking like these are some of the things that I think practitioners are noticing and it helps them, helps explain why they might be like, “Oh, there’s a lot- Yeah
to this non-verbal stuff,” because they’ve seen- Yeah … these people that I think a lot of people, if, even if you watch the interrogations with the sound off, might be like, “Oh yeah, they’re acting very shifty,” et cetera, et cetera. And again, this is not to defend the use of, uh, non-verbal behavior, but it’s to help explain why I think there’s a lot of- Yeah
like s- there are people are actually seeing these things, and then that helps them, helps them think, “Oh, there’s a lot to this non-verbal stuff. I’ve seen these things myself when I’m doing the interrogations.” But I just wanted to get your, your thought on that as somebody who’s, who’s maybe seen some of that yourself.
I maybe wasn’t explaining this as best as I could here, but my point is that even though practitioners will often be wrong when trying to read nonverbal behavior, they will sometimes be right. Just as in deception detection studies, some people who think they can read nonverbal behavior will sometimes be right.
And then there’s the fact that practitioners will be more often focusing on the nonverbal and verbal behavior of people who they already know have a good chance of being guilty. They are much less often paying close attention to the behaviors of people who are likely to be innocent. Put another way, they are seldom focusing a lot of suspicious, skeptical attention on people who are clearly innocent, and this basic imbalance in who these practitioners spend their time focusing on in investigative scenarios is, I think, a perfect amplifier of bias.
Back to the talk.
Bob Pointer: I think firstly, um, it’s a great book, Duke, it’s a very, very good book. What I would say, um, this week, this, we’ve got the new, uh, s- season of Celebrity Traitors happening here, and there’s a, an actor called Richard E. Grant in it, and he was chosen to be a traitor. And straight after he was chosen to be a traitor, they, they all met in a room and someone said to him, “Are you a traitor?”
And he said, “Yes, I’m a traitor,” without even thinking about it. Now, that, e- equate that to interviewing. One of the things with interviewing is you try to interview people as near to the crime, uh, time of the crime as possible because they haven’t had time to formulate a story. That p- that is the same for witnesses or suspects.
Um, but if you’ve got suspects, um, and I’m, I’m quite happy to say that I’ve been wrong so many times, and I can remember one particular case where I interviewed a guy for a fraud, and he completely bamboozled me, and he got arrested later on, and he admitted, uh, to take into account what he denied to me.
Um, because I think there is this thing that we only catch the low-hanging fruit, the people who are not very good at what they do. Um, if you’re really good, then you build a story and that y- and you, you embellish it, and you do whatever you do to it. You build it on reality, but you embellish it to fit your circumstances or your point of view.
If you can, if you can say that enough to other people or to yourself, it becomes your reality And once it becomes your reality, you can withstand questioning because you are … ‘Cause where people get caught out is where they’re making it up as they go along, whereas if it’s already ingrained in your memory, and then the only way to get around that is to use techniques that came in later on, like taking their account out of sequence, ’cause it’s very hard to maintain a lie when you’re being made to go forward, made to go back.
It’s very hard to keep unless it’s real, but even for a real person, they might find that difficult. So yes, in your answer, there are bad liars, but I would say there are also very good liars who avoid detection because of that, because it is their reality rather than a lie. It becomes real to them.
Zach Elwood: Yeah, for sure.
And, and it was, and hopefully it comes across that I’m not, like, defending the use of non-verbal behavior. It’s more like I was, I’m very curious about- what police officers are thinking, like the people that would say, like, there’s a lot to this non-verbal stuff. I also think, you know, getting back to the, the complexity of things, I often think that what people are saying is, you know, I, I believe, and you, I think we’re on the same page there, what people say is so much more hugely valuable than in any of these-
Bob Pointer: Mm
Zach Elwood: non-verbal things. But the, what people say can also color our opinion of the non-verbal things too, because I’ve seen these in YouTube comments too where people are like, “This person seems so obviously guilty.” And it’s like, I think they’re being influenced by what they’re actually saying because they come across as so, you know, like a suspect might just not be answering the question, avoiding answering the question.
It’s like, and then once you have that read based on the, the verbal content, you’re gonna, that’s gonna color your perception of the non-verbal stuff, and you’re gonna be like- Yeah … “They seem really shifty non-verbally.” But it’s like, no, I think your vibe of w- of why they’re guilty is mostly coming, as it should, mostly coming from what they’re saying and the fact that they’re not answering the questions or, you know, being withholding.
So I think these things- Mm … are hard to talk about, and I think that complexity also helps explain the practitioners, some practitioners being like, “No, I think there’s, there’s something to that non-verbal stuff,” right? But I think even when, even when there’s those cases where we might be like, oh, they’re acting very shifty and suspicious non-verbally, even in those cases, what they say is so much…
That’s where all the information comes from and like why would you focus on the non-verbal stuff, uh- Mm … you know, when the, when what they say is, is so much more informational, yeah.
Bob Pointer: Yeah, I think you’re right. Um, when you’re in those situations, when it’s real time and you’re, whether it’s sales or whatever, you’ve got an agenda that you’re working to, um, to keep…
You know, the, the thing that can happen if you’re looking for non-verbal behaviors as well as what’s happening, as well as keeping to your, your script that you’ve got, et cetera, is that you get cognitive overload for yourself.
Zach Elwood: Yeah.
Bob Pointer: Um, so, so, um-
Zach Elwood: You gotta focus on the most important things, and why would you focus on the- Exactly
why would you focus on the least important things?
Bob Pointer: Yeah, exactly. But I mean, what, where behavior, if you look back, we, we were non-verbal in our evolution, and then we became verbal. It, so back when we were non-verbal it meant everything, but then we didn’t converse with people other than to ward off people, um, or whatever, uh, in those environments.
And now because we’ve got talk, that has become our main means of communication. It’s the only thing that can be used in evidence in the UK. And I can say that until I retired in 2008 In interviewing, we were not taught non-verbal behavior. We focused entirely on verbal behavior, because that is evidence.
Zach Elwood: Mm-hmm.
Bob Pointer: Anything else is not evidence. Yeah. And what you would rely on, and I know you’ve had Vincent DiNozzo on, and I, I, you know, we don’t go down the route of where judges may comment on behavior, but the behavior will be on show when the jury see them.
Zach Elwood: Mm-hmm.
Bob Pointer: Um, and that is the only time, I think, that where behavior analysis of suspects occurred, but I can’t say for now because I’ve been retired since, well, a long while ago, nearly 20 years ago, so it may have changed.
I don’t know. Yeah. Now, but certainly in terms of legal matters, it’s not. But behavior is important, don’t get me wrong. It is very important, but it has to be taken in context and like I say, you have to look at the moment. The thing with Ekman and things like that is, is that you haven’t got time to, one, to look for macro behavior, let alone micro behavior within an interview.
But when you’re looking at it, we all know, we all read body language. We all do it, we just are informed, informed operators. But the, the easiest, the thing that I teach people is a thing called valance, and that is much easier to teach, is, is this behavior towards us, away from us, or is it in the middle somewhere?
And that’s all you really need to know. Is this behavior positive or negative?
Zach Elwood: Mm.
Bob Pointer: And that’s, that’s all you need to know, and then you can actually give the bandwidth in what you’re thinking to, “Well, why? Why am I thinking that?” A- and, and, and then wait and think, “Well, maybe I’ll go back and ask that question again or I’ll see if he beh- if, if that behavior surfaces again, and this time I’ll look for what I said before.”
Zach Elwood: In the behavior expert space, ’cause I think it’s important to separate things into, like, the low stakes domain of our everyday- Mm. You know, most of our- Yeah … everyday social interactions where people- Mm … are mostly not trying to hide things, and then, like, more high stakes adversarial things. I think what behavior- Mm
experts, as, you know, so-called behavior experts, I think they basically are overcomplicating things because they’ll often say, like-
Bob Pointer: Yeah … “
Zach Elwood: People don’t pay attention to body language at all. People don’t know how to read body language.” Yeah. It’s like, no, we’re all reading body language- Yeah … every day, and it’s- Always
Bob Pointer: wrong
Zach Elwood: you know, it, it, get, yeah, we’re, we’re monitoring how people react to us, you know. And that, that helps explain, like, the banality of a lot of the, the stuff that behavior experts teach, because you can read Amazon reviews where people are like, “This is all completely obvious, like, I know almost all this stuff.”
Yeah. And it’s, and it’s because we’re, most of us, and, and leaving aside, like, people on the more autistic spectrum, uh, and that’s, and that’s a- another area where I think the more autistic spectrum people can find a lot of value in behavior expert stuff, because it is not obvious to them. But for a lot of people, they’ll read these books and be like, “This is all completely obvious.
Like, these are the things I’m using every day. Like, I’ll-“
Bob Pointer: Mm.
Zach Elwood: You know, in my work- Yeah, yeah … or my interpersonal, I, I, I notice when people are acting, you know, nervous, and I, I use that to adjust my behavior. I notice when they’re acting irritated. I notice when their brow furrows, because it shows that they’re thinking about something.
You know, these are all things that we’re all, most of us are, are, are monitoring every day- Yeah … which I think helps explain the banality of it to a lot of people. Yeah. But then it’s like they’re also trying to say that these things are, are valuable in the high stakes arenas where it just is not shown to be- Yeah
because those are- Yeah … arenas where many people are anxious, many people are irritated. So to try to take the same signals that we use in day-to-day life in these adversarial, uh, arenas is just doomed to failure and doomed to bad reads and bad, you know, confirmation bias and so on. But anyway, I just wanted to throw that in as I think that’s related to some of the stuff- Yeah
we’ve talked about, yeah.
Bob Pointer: Yeah, I think it’s important to say as well that all behavior means something, but not all of it is meaningful in the context of what you’re talking about. You have to, you know, be nuanced enough that you can see, well, yeah, that’s just behavior, that’s… But it doesn’t mean anything for what we’re talking about.
Zach Elwood: Right. This has been great. Uh, really appreciate you coming on to talk to me.
Bob Pointer: No, it’s been a pleasure. Thank you.
Zach Elwood: That was a talk with Bob Poynter. You can learn more about him and his work at bi-ac.com. That’s B-I for behavioral intelligence, and A-C for academy. This has been the People Who Read People podcast with me, Zach Ellwood.
You can learn more about it at behavior-podcast.com. Music by Small Skies.